ICE 2012 Audits at all Time High
By: Tommy Eden, Attorney
Last year was the busiest year on record for the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) audits of employers' Form I-9s. Investigations, fines and arrests grew dramatically for I-9 violations and the numbers breakdown as follows:
10 Fold Increase in Audits Since 2009: In fiscal year 2007, ICE conducted only 250 audits. In contrast in 2012, ICE I-9 audits rose to more than 3,000.
13 Fold Increase in Fines Since 2009: From 2009 until 2012, fines for I-9 violations grew from $1 million to $13 million. Easy fine money for ICE auditors.
Increased Arrests: The number of company owners, executives and managers arrested during ICE investigations increased to 238.
Industries and Small Businesses Targeted: ICE has made a determined effort to audit companies of all sizes and in all industries ranging from General Electric to a small Subway franchise have been fined for I-9 violations. ICE publicized the conviction of a Dunkin' Donuts manager who knowingly hired unauthorized workers and was sentenced to house arrest. Texas had the highest number of ICE workplace fines in 2011, followed by New Jersey.
ICE Notice of Intent to Fine Process: Employers do have options to defend against an ICE notice of intent to fine (NIF). An employer who receives a NIF may appeal within stated deadlines to the U.S. Department of Justice and request a hearing before the Office of the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer. If ICE pursues the case after a hearing is requested, an Administrative Law Judge will hear the matter. For a company contacted by ICE for an audit having legal representation during the investigation or appeal stage can be beneficial.
Reduction of Fine Procedure: Recent decisions after appeal have led to substantial reductions in the fines that were assessed by ICE. Companies issued NIFs have the option to appeal in an effort to reduce the impact of I-9 violations claimed against them.
Private Audits Advisable Before ICE Knocks: The best advice to employers is to begin 2013 with an internal audit of I-9 records - before the employer receives a notice or subpoena from ICE. An audit of I-9s conducted by a qualified professional is a risk reduction investment in creating a compliance program that can prevent I-9 violations, fines and arrests.
Common Sense Counsel: Training on how to properly complete the new Form I-9 is easy and will help you avoid fines and penalties after May 7, 2013.
Tommy Eden of the Constangy Firm and Rosemary Elebash, Alabama State Director of the NFIB did a Webinar on
Untangling the New Form I-9 Training for the Alabama Cooperative Extension System which link is at
www.immigrationalabamalaw.com as are the new Forms and Employer Handbook.
Tommy Eden is an attorney with Constangy, Brooks & Smith, LLP, member of the ABA Section of Labor and Employment Law, East Alabama SHRM Board of Directors and presented throughout the State of
Alabama on Immigration Workplace Compliance. Tommy can be contacted at
teden@constangy.com or 334-246-2901.
Link to Constangy, Brooks & Smith, LLP Webinar – Untangling the New Form I-9 with 3 Constangy Attorneys
Link to Alabama Cooperative Extension System Webinar – Untangling the New Form I-9 interview format in 10 segments.
http://www.aces.edu/events/